The Annual Installment
The basic premise for determining the amount of an annual installment is relatively straightforward:
Divide the total amount of tax deferred under section 6166 by the number of installments that were selected for its payment (a minimum of 2 to a maximum of 10).
Example:
5,139,475.74 | Total tax deferred under section 6166, divided by |
10 | Number of annual installments selected |
513,947.57 | Annual installment |
Variation:
5,139,475.74 | Total tax deferred under section 6166, divided by |
6 | Number of annual installments selected |
856,579.29 | Annual installment |
However, IRS audit adjustments, interim payments, and other factors can make the determination of the annual installment more difficult and, in some cases, counterintuitive. It is important to distinguish between
- The annual installment, and
- The amount of the annual installment currently payable.
In many cases prepayment credits resulting from interim payments or supplemental return computations will generate two different numbers.
The Annual Installment, Comment 1: This concept is further explained in, e.g., Rev. Rul. 81-294 and Rev. Rul. 81-294 Illustrated. |
Code section 6166(a) provides:
§6166. Extension of time for payment of estate tax where estate consists largely of interest in closely held business
(a) 5-year deferral; 10-year installment payment
(1) In general
If the value of an interest in a closely held business which is included in determining the gross estate of a decedent who was (at the date of his death) a citizen or resident of the United States exceeds 35 percent of the adjusted gross estate, the executor may elect to pay part or all of the tax imposed by section 2001 in 2 or more (but not exceeding 10) equal installments.
(2) Limitation
The maximum amount of tax which may be paid in installments under this subsection shall be an amount which bears the same ratio to the tax imposed by section 2001 (reduced by the credits against such tax) as-
(A) the closely held business amount, bears to
(B) the amount of the adjusted gross estate.
(3) Date for payment of installments
If an election is made under paragraph (1), the first installment shall be paid on or before the date selected by the executor which is not more than 5 years after the date prescribed by section 6151(a) for payment of the tax, and each succeeding installment shall be paid on or before the date which is 1 year after the date prescribed by this paragraph for payment of the preceding installment.
Reg. §20.6166-1(e)(2) provides:
(2) Determination of date for payment of first installment. The executor may defer payment of tax (but not interest) for any period up to 5 years from the date determined under section 6151(a) for payment of the estate tax. The date chosen for payment of the first installment of tax is not required to be on an annual anniversary of the original due date of the tax; however, it must be the date within any month which corresponds to the day of the month determined under section 6151(a).
Example:
Feb-17-2016 | Date of death |
Nov-17-2016 | Section 6075(a) return due date |
May-17-2017 | Section 6081 extended return filing due date. The return is filed with a regular §6166(a) 14-year election. |
Nov-17-2017 | 1st anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2018 | 2nd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2019 | 3rd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2020 | 4th anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2021 | 5th anniversary date and §6166(a)(3) 1st installment due date, with 9 successive Nov-17 installment due dates to follow |
Variation 1:
Feb-17-2016 | Date of death |
Nov-17-2016 | Section 6075(a) return due date |
May-17-2017 | Section 6081 extended return filing due date. The return is filed with a regular §6166(a) 14-year election. Because of cash flow considerations, the estate selects an installment due date of July 1, 2021. |
Nov-17-2017 | 1st anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2018 | 2nd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2019 | 3rd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Nov-17-2020 | 4th anniversary date - only interest is due |
Jul-17-2021 | 5th anniversary date and §6166(a)(3) first installment due date pursuant to the statutory modification to the election by Cincinnati Campus (this does occur). |
Variation 2:
May-31-2015 | Date of death |
Feb-29-2016 | Section 6075(a) return due date |
Aug-29-2016 | Section 6081 extended return filing due date. The return is filed with a regular §6166(a) 14-year election. |
Feb-28-2017 | 1st anniversary date modified pursuant to Reg. §20.6075-1 for a non-leap year - only interest is due |
Feb-28-2018 | 2nd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Feb-28-2019 | 3rd anniversary date - only interest is due |
Feb-29-2020 | 4th anniversary date modified pursuant to Reg. §20.6075-1 for a leap year - only interest is due |
Feb-28-2021 | 5th anniversary date and §6166(a)(3) first installment due date, modified pursuant to Reg. §20.6075-1 for a non-leap year. |
Feb-28-2022 | 6th anniversary date and 2nd installment due date. |
Feb-28-2023 | 7th anniversary date and 3rd installment due date. |
Feb-29-2024 | 8th anniversary date and 4th installment due date, and so on. |
Note that in all section 6166(b)(7), (b)(8), or (b)(10) elections the first installment is due on the original return due date determined without regard to any extensions of time to file. In the section 6166 notice of election filed with the return, an executor could elect to shorten the deferral period from the applicable maximum number of installments to a minimum of 2 installments.
Annual Installment Computation Examples
Annual Installment Example 1 | A very basic example. The return is filed on the return due date with a regular 14-year §6166(a) election. The non-deferred tax is paid with the return. |
Annual Installment Example 2 | The return is filed on the 6-month extended return due date with a regular 14-year §6166(a) election. The non-deferred tax shown on the return is greater than the estimated non-deferred tax that was paid with the filing of Form 4768. A catch-up payment of the balance of non-deferred tax and interest on that sum is submitted with the return. |
Annual Installment Example 3 | The return is filed on the 6-month extended return due date with a 9-year §6166(b)(7) family attribution election. The non-deferred tax shown on the return is greater than the estimated non-deferred tax that was paid with the filing of Form 4768. The first installment of deferred tax was also due with the Form 4768 but is paid with the return. A catch-up payment of the balance of non-deferred tax, the first installment of deferred tax, and interest on that sum is submitted with the return. |
Annual Installment Example 4 | The return is filed on the 6-month extended return due date with a 9-year §6166(b)(8) holding company election. The non-deferred tax shown on the return is less than the estimated non-deferred tax that was paid with the filing of Form 4768. The first installment of deferred tax was also due with the Form 4768. The overpayment of non-deferred tax is applied against the first installment. A catch-up payment of the balance of the first installment of deferred tax and interest on that sum is submitted with the return. |
Annual Installment Example 5 | Periodic voluntary tax payments are made during the course of a regular §6166(a) 14-year election deferral period. The payments reduce the base on which interest is computed but do not change the annual installment amount. The payments are applied as credits against the annual installments as they come due. The author had one case at the service center level where, by the midpoint of the 14-year extension, well over 100 voluntary payments had been submitted. This did not create any undue hardship for the IRS. |
6601(j) Example 1 | This example illustrates the annual installments for the 4 types of section 6166 deferrals in light of the section 6601(j) interest computations. |